Op-Ed: The Need For New York Yidden To Obtain Firearms

Photo courtesy of NYS Jewish Gun Club

Jewish safety has always been an issue in NY. The frum community, who stand out as obvious Jews, has long been a target for attacks. We need the ability to protect ourselves by ourselves, and embrace our right to bear arms to deter the threats against us.

Submitted to the FrumNews.com inbox

Jewish safety has always been an issue in New York. The frum community, who stand out as obvious Jews, has long been a target for hate crimes and anti-Semitism.

For many years, community leaders have petitioned City Hall to increase the presence of NYPD officers in our neighborhoods. Every administration has ignored the issue and only ramped up security for the days following a violent attack. In this time of heightened terror activities and daily threats, we can no longer rely on the city for our protection.

First and foremost, While security precautions—which includes firearms—are essential to the security of our Kehillah, we should not forget that as Yidden, our ultimate defense and security guarantee is our Emunah in Hashem.

We also need the ability to protect ourselves by ourselves. In addition to much needed more police officers to patrol our streets, we frum Yidden must consider legally arming ourselves as the first barrier of defense. Even at the best of times, the fastest enforcement response can mean that minutes pass before police are on the scene of a violent incident.

Just as our wonderful Hatzalah was established as a way for us to take care of our own needs in our best way, we need to shift our security mindset and embrace our right to bear arms to deter the threats against us.

The process is straightforward and easier than many believe. With the mandatory NYS firearm safety classes given by Heimishe NRA certified instructors in every large frum community and neighborhood in New York City and State. It is possible now to get approved for a New York Pistol License and in fact many in our community have already acquired their NYC or NYS concealed carry permit.

The more Frum Yidden that exercise their right to carry a legal firearm and sign up for gun safety training courses, the safer we will all be. It is not meant for everyone in our community, but if enough mature, responsible Yingurleit apply for their firearms permits and are armed, we will no longer have to wait many minutes for law enforcement when there are possibly no minutes to spare in case of a major sakanah incident c”v.

Eventually, we won’t need to outsource the security of our yeshivas and shuls to security companies who are less familiar with our communities and the threats we face. Many out-of-town communities already have frum security companies, hiring local members of their Kehilla who combine their knowledge and understanding of how frum moisdos operate with top-notch protection.

***

The views expressed here 100% reflect the views of FrumNews.com. Otherwise, we would not have published this opinion piece.

Share your opinion! Email, opinion@FrumNews.com or click here.

*

Editor’s note FrumNews.com would like to remind our readers, that obtaining your concealed carry permit is one aspect, but make time to practice, practice and practice. There is never enough training that one can do. Purchase a proper home safe for when you are not carrying. And most importantly Daven and be mispalel that you will never have to use it.

Post your comments:

Your Comment *
Your Title *

16 Comments

  • Yakov 11/17/2024 | ט"ז חשון התשפ"ה

    Gun rights are Jewish rights

  • Jack 11/10/2024 | ט' חשון התשפ"ה

    Gun rights is Jewish rights

  • DrJJ 10/29/2024 | כ"ז תשרי התשפ"ה

    Bring back the Jewish Defense League”!

    The only thing That has ever stopped Hateful and violent Antisemites Is overwhelming force!

    Were Israel to rely solely on international
    Goodwill For protection Historically Would have been the end of Israel!

    Said to say the Islamists,,Helped largely by the Harris/Biden weak immigration
    controls. Has now been Imported on a large scale into the U.S.
    Just another disastrous outcome For America in general and Jews in particular, Courtesy of the totally incompetent& Solely politically motivated Biden/Harris admin!.!

    I seriously question Israel’s survival Should
    Harris by Hook or crook become POTUS!

  • Eli 09/18/2024 | ט"ו אלול התשפ"ד

    Training, training, training. That is the important point. Training needs to be more than just shooting at a paper target.
    I strongly suggest taking an active shooter training course. These courses are designed to put you under extreme stress. A lot of these courses use simulation ammo which is basially a bullet filled with water color. There is a HUGE difference between shooting at a paper target and when someone is shooting back at you.

  • NY yidden should move to Texas 09/12/2024 | ט' אלול התשפ"ד

    When I lived in NY, I applied for a carry permit because my delivery business collected large sums daily for COD deliveries. After 6 months, I was denied and offered a premise permit, which meant I couldn’t carry the gun outside of my business premises.

    Then I moved to Texas, and got a carry permit immediately.

  • Could be dumb. 09/10/2024 | ז' אלול התשפ"ד

    Friendly fire is especially dangerous in close-quarters combat because everything happens fast and in tight spaces. With everyone so close together, it’s easy for shots to hit the wrong person. One mistake could cause serious harm or death.

    The more people you arm the bigger chance you have of more casualties on your side. Which might not be better than the alternative.

  • Mr. Levy 09/09/2024 | ו' אלול התשפ"ד

    Problem is if you ever have to use it you will most likely be put in jail. Unless of course you stop that one lone terrorist. But it most cases if you use a firearm to defend yourself against antisemitism you will be the one sitting behind bars. This is NYC.

  • October 7th changed everthing 08/19/2024 | ט"ו אב התשפ"ד

    Many Jews in New York City & State felt that there was never a need to be armed, but October 7 changed everything.

    At this point, anyone that has the capability to apply for their firearm license, properly train & practice, that doesn’t – is simply foolish.

    Many in NYC fear that if there’s a summer blackout, a certain candidate wins the U.S. election, or some other “reason” for unrest, then the 2020 BLM riots will be nothing compared to what can happen.

    Additionally there have been many anti-Israel protests in and in very close proximity to the Jewish communities in Brooklyn, some have turned violent and Jews got injured.

    Let’s not forget the “Free Palestine” stabbing attack that just happened in Crown Heights, as well as smaller incidents that happened in Williamsburg and Flatbush.

    We need to do our part spiritually and have faith in Hashem. Physically we also need to be ready if and when it’s needed

  • Licensed Armed Guard 06/30/2024 | כ"ד סיון התשפ"ד

    Yes, but it is dangerously irresponsible to carry a deadly weapon in a crowded shul or neighborhood without the training to assess threats and respond to them appropriately. That is more than a gun safety course. That is ongoing training in security and
    marksmanship, as well as regular practice on a gun range.

    Hitting the target you want to hit at anything farther than a few yards in a crisis situation with blood pumping is not easy. That is why the formation of frum security firms is so important. As a member of one such group I am involved in training a few times a month in firearms, anti- terrorism, trauma care and, most importantly, de-escalation.

    But whether or not u become a licensed armed guard,if u choose to arm yourself, arm yourself with more than a deadly weapon. Arm yourself- and your kehilla – with the knowledge, training, and muscle memory to use that weapon safely and effectively.

  • Menachem Goldstein 06/24/2024 | י"ח סיון התשפ"ד

    It’s a bad idea. The “good guy with a gun” only works for people who have the time to get properly trained. But you did mention that in the second last paragraph.

  • Kop DR 06/24/2024 | י"ח סיון התשפ"ד

    Yes it’s. About time I am ready for training

  • Nn 06/24/2024 | י"ח סיון התשפ"ד

    Who is going to decide who is mature and responsible? Bc there are plenty who may not be.

    There should be a vetting process.

Post your comments:

Your Comment *
Your Title *