Book Review: Who’s Afraid of the Big, Bad Jew: Learning to Love the Lessons of Jew-Hatred

In Who’s Afraid of the Big, Bad Jew: Learning to Love the Lessons of Jew-Hatred, Rabbi Raphael Shore offers a bold and transformative exploration of the age-old scourge of antisemitism. This compelling work goes beyond recounting historical atrocities: it reclaims Jewish identity as a force for moral clarity and societal progress.

Shore’s thesis is provocative yet empowering: antisemitism, far from being rooted in mere hate, often stems from a subconscious recognition of Judaism’s enduring ethical impact on civilization, triggering anger precisely because Jews embody transformative ideals like justice, conscience, and compassion.

Shore diverges from typical victim-centered narratives by reframing antisemitism as a distorted compliment, an admission that Jewish values are potent and world-changing. As Gil Troy aptly writes, the book’s striking cover of a muscular Jew towering over caricatures of Hitler, Hamas terrorists, and radical activists mirrors its unapologetic thesis: haters fear Jewish power, not weakness.

The strength of Shore’s work lies in its multidimensional approach. We’re guided through centuries of persecution with clear historical analysis, then grounded in Jewish theology, reminding readers that these trials are intertwined with a divinely inspired mission. Shore shares candid personal narratives, his transition from a secular upbringing in Canada to a spiritual renaissance in Israel that anchor the broader arguments with emotional authenticity.

The endorsements speak volumes. Ambassador David Friedman calls it “the right book at the right time,” Dennis Prager calls it among the best-written on antisemitism, Bob Diener deems it a “wake-up call,” and Alan Dershowitz praises Shore’s ability to ask and answer the right questions. These attestations highlight both its literary quality and its relevance in today’s fraught global climate.

Shore avoids the trap of despair. Instead, he urges Jews and their allies to embrace Jewish identity fully, to wear it with moral confidence, and to challenge injustice wherever it arises. It’s a call to proactive Jewish selfhood: being “a light unto the nations.” The narrative dispels fatalism and replaces it with purpose.

With global antisemitism on the rise, Shore’s timing is vital. He confronts contemporary expressions from campus hostility to geopolitical slander with historical insight and theological depth.

Shore writes with clarity, conviction, and warmth. The book is structured to guide readers thoughtfully, using anecdotes, scriptural analysis, and cultural critique. Each chapter builds, first by revealing antisemitism’s roots, then by offering hope rooted in Jewish values. The tone is urgent without being alarmist, introspective but never self-pitying.

This book is a clarion call to Jews and allies. It challenges readers to stop seeing Jewish history through a lens of victimhood and instead to embody the power of Jewish values. Shore asks the essential question: why fade into the background when antisemitism reveals Jewish influence? His answer: harness that influence to advance justice, compassion, and conscience in the world.

This is a must-read for Orthodox Jewish individuals seeking empowerment and identity affirmation, allies committed to understanding and confronting antisemitism, educators and community leaders navigating rising intolerance, and anyone interested in moral philosophy rooted in ancient tradition.

Final Verdict: 5/5 stars

Rabbi Raphael Shore has crafted a fiercely honest, deeply rooted, and ultimately liberating narrative. This book compels readers not just to remember Jewish suffering but to recognize Jewish strength and significance. Especially in these challenging times, it serves as both shield and beacon, a testament to resilience and a blueprint for a morally courageous future. Kol Hakavod, Rabbi Shore!

Purchase a copy here: